FREE!      Cameratown Newsletter
NEW!       Zacuto Z-Finder V2 Review

Home New Models Cameras News Deals Video Reviews Firmware Manuals Free Software Rebates Shopping

Cameratown Sponsors





Add This Page to Stumble Upon




Digital Photography Reviews

View All Product Reviews Back to Referring Page

Canon Powershot S3 IS VS Sony Cyber-shot DSC-H5 Review

Review Summary
Reader Score: 7.36 (out of 10)
Side-by-Side Review: The Canon Powershot S3 IS and the Sony Cybershot DSC-H5 are two very capable and compact all-round cameras and when you have to travel light they are the ultimate partners. They are consumer cameras due to absence of AdobeRGB and RAW, and responsiveness and image quality do not stand up to that of d-SLR's. With their manual controls however they are more than point-and-shoot cameras and can fulfil the wishes of even the more demanding amateur.

On most points the Powershot S3 leaves the Sony H5 behind, but the latter has a very appealing LCD and resolution and image quality (besides the CA) are better. The colors of the H5 are somewhat more natural and the visible noise is less at higher ISO's. Both cameras can make breathtaking macros and very nice movies. The cameras are each others equals and won't disappoint its usersegment: all-round (travel) photography."

After reading this FULL REVIEW
Let others know if it was informative
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Other Reviews For This Model

Review Site Review Score Date Link
DPReview 9.25 07-04-06 Read Full Review
Review: "Like the H2, the H5 improves on its predecessor (the highly-praised DSC-H1) in several small but significant ways, both in terms of features and in the all-important matter of image quality. What it doesn't offer is a significant step up from the H2 in any respect (bigger, sharper screen aside).

Compared to the most obvious competitors - the Canon S3 IS and Panasonic DMC-FZ7 - the Sony H5 scores highly in handling, features, overall image quality and ease of use, and only really falls short in a couple of areas..."



Review Site Review Score Date Link
DCResource 9.21 05-27-06 Read Full Review
Review: "The Cyber-shot DSC-H5 ($500) is Sony's top-end ultra zoom camera. The H5's features include a 7.2 Megapixel CCD, 12X optical zoom lens with image stabilization, full manual controls, a VGA movie mode, and a huge 3-inch LCD.

Focusing performance was very good on the H5. Typically it took between 0.2 and 0.4 seconds to lock focus, and longer at the telephoto end of the lens. While it won't win any awards for speed, the DSC-H5 focused reliably every time in low light.

Even with a few flaws, the Sony Cyber-shot DSC-H5 is still one of the best ultra zoom cameras on the market. It offers a high resolution sensor (with low noise levels through ISO 400), a 12X zoom lens, optical image stabilization, and an enormous 3-inch LCD display. Downsides are few, and they include above average purple fringing and a so-so continuous shooting mode."



Review Site Review Score Date Link
CNET Reviews 9.00 05-30-06 Read Full Review
Review: "Sony's Cyber Shot DSC-H5 sits at the top of the company's current crop of megazoom cameras. Fittingly, it has all the specs you'd expect in a camera of its class, including a large, image-stabilized 12X optical zoom lens, a 3-inch LCD screen, a 7.2-megapixel CCD sensor, and a full set of manual controls. Step-up snapshooters, soccer moms, and even some advanced amateurs will find that the Cyber Shot DSC-H5 has a lot to offer. The huge zoom range is great for occasions when you want versatility but don't want to lug around a DSLR and a ton of lenses. Plus, the wide maximum aperture of f/2.8, along with the image stabilization, helps in low light. Unfortunately, this camera's higher ISOs yields so much noise that picky low-light shooters will want to look elsewhere."

Review Site Review Score Date Link
NEOCamera 8.83 01-10-07 Read Full Review
Review: "Do not be alarmed by the long list of pros and cons here, the Sony Cybershot DSC-H5 is a good camera. Since several technical review sites have seen this camera, it has been scrutinized quite a bit. The H5 does improve significantly on its predecessor, the H1and even does a few things better than the Sony Cybershot DSC-H2.

With so many features packed in a light camera body, the Sony Cybershot DSC-H5 has tremendous consumer appeal. Its 7 megapixels sensor, stabilized 12X optical zoom, 3" LCD and highly saturated colors are designed to impress people looking for a more-is-better type of camera. The H5 has enough resolution for common print sizes and even midsize ones (10"x13") under ideal conditions..."



Review Site Review Score Date Link
Imaging-Resource 8.71 07-15-06 Read Full Review
Review: "The Sony Cyber-shot DSC-H5 offers a sensor resolution of seven megapixels along with a new Carl Zeiss Vario-Tessar 12x optical zoom lens with 58mm threading and Super SteadyShot optical image stabilization. Other features include ISO sensitivity from ISO 80 to 1,000, a choice of both aperture- and shutter-priority plus a fully manual mode, 32MB of internal memory, and a three-inch LCD display. Battery life is rated at 340 shots.

The Sony H5 provides more manual exposure control than many other long zoom digital cameras, yet is easy to use in full-auto mode, and its seven pre-programmed scene modes help with tricky subjects. The design and layout of the H5 is very user-friendly, and the camera boasts accurate EVF and LCD displays."



Review Site Review Score Date Link
DCViews 7.82 07-10-06 Read Full Review
Side-by-Side Review: The Canon Powershot S3 IS and the Sony Cybershot DSC-H5 are two very capable and compact all-round cameras and when you have to travel light they are the ultimate partners. They are consumer cameras due to absence of AdobeRGB and RAW, and responsiveness and image quality do not stand up to that of d-SLR's. With their manual controls however they are more than point-and-shoot cameras and can fulfil the wishes of even the more demanding amateur.

On most points the Powershot S3 leaves the Sony H5 behind, but the latter has a very appealing LCD and resolution and image quality (besides the CA) are better. The colors of the H5 are somewhat more natural and the visible noise is less at higher ISO's. Both cameras can make breathtaking macros and very nice movies. The cameras are each others equals and won't disappoint its usersegment: all-round (travel) photography."



Review Site Review Score Date Link
Digital Camera Info 7.68 07-31-06 Read Full Review
Head to Head: "Consumers with somewhere upwards of $400 or $500 to spend on a compact camera can get plenty of great features – long telephoto zooms, movie capability, and 6-to-7-megapixel files. We looked at three leading cameras in this category: the Canon PowerShot S3 IS, the Sony Cyber-shot DSC-H5, and the Panasonic Lumix DMC-FZ7. We found similarities and differences. All three cameras are capable, but the differences are significant enough that most users will have a clear favorite.

The Canon PowerShot S3 IS, Panasonic Lumix DMC-FZ7, and the Sony Cyber-shot DSC-H5 are closely matched in terms of image quality and performance. Their lenses have identical focal length ranges and very similar apertures. Their dimensions are close, and they are equally portable. For their target market, snapshooters who want some extra capabilities, all of the cameras are acceptable. However, there are clearly areas where each excels. While a clear winner is tough to distinguish, the cameras do differ substantially, with each offering advantages in certain types of situations."



Review Site Review Score Date Link
Megapixel 7.00 08-05-06 Read Full Review
Review: "In general appearance, the Sony Cyber-shot DSC-H5 is a twin of the DSC-H2, sharing both body design and instruction manual. Like the H2, the H5 offers a 12X stabilized Carl Zeiss zoom, but adds a 3-inch LCD monitor instead of the 2-inch monitor of the H2. The critical difference however, is internal: the H5 has a different CCD, which gives it a 7.2-megapixel resolution.

At the wide end of the zoom, the Carl Zeiss optics of the H5 are effectively free of distortion, and only photos of subjects a short distance away from the lens show any trace of barrel distortion, while at the telephoto end of the zoom, the image is consistently distortion-free.

Interestingly, when it comes to chromatic aberration - purple fringing - the H5, with its 7.2-megapixel CCD, seems to be less sensitive than the H2 and its 6-megapixel CCD. Although it should be pointed out that the phenomenon is light with the H2."



Review Site Review Score Date Link
Digital Camera Info 6.72 06-02-06 Read Full Review
Review: 'The Sony Cyber-shot DSC-H5 was released as the flagship of the ultra-zoom line. Along with the H2, it succeeds the H1, which had a solo release. The H5 has specifications worthy of its role: 7.1 megapixels on a 1/2.5-inch Super HAD CCD, a Carl Zeiss branded 12x optical zoom lens with image stabilization, and 32 MB of internal memory.

he Sony H5 is not without flaws though. All of its goodness comes at a price – and the $499 retail isn’t the worst of it. The large LCD screen and excellent stabilization system are great, but they suck the AA batteries dry too quickly. If users want to actually employ the functional manual mode and all of the camera’s settings and features, they’ll need bags full of batteries just to get through a day of shooting."



Review Site Review Score Date Link
PC Magazine ----- 01-24-07 Read Full Review
Review: "On the surface, the Sony Cyber-shot DSC-H5 has plenty of the allure that makes Sony cameras and camcorders popular: provocative design and a bunch of features that everybody seems to want. For example, the Sony H5 has a bright three-inch LCD and a whopping 12X optical zoom that gives you the feeling you've got all the photo control you'll ever need.

In my view, the H5 doesn't quite live up to its compelling design. Namely, I found some significant shutter lag as well as some fringing which keeps this shooter from getting a higher rating..."



Twitter Counter for @cameratown







HOT DEALS
 
Samsung HMX-R10 Digital HD Flash Hybrid Camcorder (9MP Stills)
Price: $299.99
TigerDirect
Canon Speedlite 430EX II Hot-Shoe Flash
Price: $248~
BuyDig
Canon EOS 5D Mark II - Lowest Price Yet
Price: $2439~
42nd St. Photo
Canon Powershot SX120 IS - Use Coupon: EMCMMMX39
Price: $189.99
NewEgg
 
Copyright @2003-2008 Cameratown.com. All Rights Reserved. Terms of Use
All Rights Reserved. Reproduction in any form or medium without the
express written permission of Cameratown.com is prohibited.
Please email me with your suggestions or comments.