Digital Photography Reviews
|
| View All Product Reviews |
Back to Referring Page |
Sony Cyber-shot DSC-R1 Review
|
Review Summary
Reader Score: 8.67 (out of 10)
"The Sony Cyber-shot DSC-R1 is a ground-breaking bridge camera, using a 10.3 megapixel CMOS sensor developed by Sony. The camera is equipped with a 5X optical zoom from Carl Zeiss that has a focal length equivalent to a 24 to140 mm, a 2-inch hinged monitor, and an electronic viewfinder (EVF).
The exterior of the DSC-R1 is covered in a tough polycarbonate-type black plastic with a granite texture, covering a metallic skeleton whose presence is betrayed by the relatively heavy weight of the R1 (approximately 1 kilo or 2.2 lbs).
The colour reproduction of the R1 is excellent. With the camera set to its default setting for saturation, colours are true-to-life and the image processing avoids making colours overly vibrant. In part this is due to the fact that the Auto white balance is reliable and, works well under varied circumstances."
|
|
Other Reviews For This Model
| Review Site |
Review Score |
Date |
Link |
| Outback Photo |
9.33 |
12-08-05 |
Read Full Review
|
| Digital Outback Photo has started their review that will be published in diary form. As they use the R1 they'll publish their thoughts and findings. Some of the initial comments posted are:
- We find the range of the zoom with 24-120mm (135 equivalent) very useful. Restricting the zoom range allows to build better lenses.
- We expect the R1 to behave much better in terms of image quality because the APS sized sensor (about the same size as used in the Canon 20D and not a lot smaller than used in the Nikon DSLRs). For such a sized sensor 10MP makes sense but the 8MP were overkill for the small digicam sensors.
- Don't expect us to fall in love with the R1 EVF. But in some way it feels better than the one from the F828 and the manual focus is quite well implemented.
|
|
| Review Site |
Review Score |
Date |
Link |
| A-Digital-Eye |
8.60 |
12-16-05 |
Read Full Review
|
| Sony intends to create a new benchmark in digital photography with the introduction of its high-end Cyber-shot® DSC-R1 camera.
The Cyber-shot® R1 camera is the world's first integrated lens digital still camera to combine a professional-grade, 10.3-megapixel image sensor and the flexibility of live (pre)view while shooting. With its ultra-wide Carl Zeiss Vario-Sonnar T* zoom lens (24mm - 120mm) and free-angle, two-inch LCD, the Cyber-shot R1 brings professional level imaging performance to mainstream consumers.
Image quality of R1 is extremely high. At low ISO's, R1 is able to capture lots of detail. Sharpness and color are excellent. The default sharpening is not very high, which is good because most buyers would prefer sharpen in post processing. Color balance seems just right, neither too saturated nor too dull.
R1 is the first digital camera to offer an APS-C sized sensor combined with a lens-integral design. It offers an impressive feature set at a competitive price (after you factor in the cost of a decent lens for a DSLR). Impressive not only on paper, but the images it delivers. They are detailed and nicely saturated with very little noise capable of very large enlargements. Combined with easy operation, it becomes the perfect camera for a variety of situations. But R1 is clearly not for everyone. For those seeking more flexibility (like shooting action and sports), you'd be better looking at DSLR's. There are drawbacks for each type of cameras; but for the things R1 is designed for, it does them very well. |
|
| Review Site |
Review Score |
Date |
Link |
| DPReview |
8.44 |
12-06-05 |
Read Full Review
|
| "..it's not the body design which makes this camera unique (many have copied the DSC-D700), it is the camera's sensor and lens. This is the first all-in-one digital camera to utilize a large (APS size) sensor, to be precise a 10.3 megapixel CMOS unit measuring 21.5 x 14.4 mm which is essentially a slightly smaller version of the sensor used in the Nikon D2X. It's also the first APS size sensor to provide full time live preview to the camera's LCD monitor or EVF (electronic viewfinder). This means that there's no mirror box or prism making the camera more compact and allowing the lens to be positioned much closer to the sensor. Equally as important and interesting is the lens which provides a 24 - 120 mm (equivalent) five times zoom with a maximum aperture of F2.8 - F4.8." |
|
| Review Site |
Review Score |
Date |
Link |
| DCResource |
8.00 |
11-23-05 |
Read Full Review
|
| Recommending the Sony Cyber-shot DSC-R1 is a no-brainer: it's a great camera. Recommending it over a digital SLR is more difficult, and it's a decision that ultimately comes down to what trade-offs you're willing to make. When comparing the R1 to other fixed-lens cameras, you're gaining excellent photo quality and a super lens and only (really) giving up a movie mode. When compared to digital SLRs you're giving up the optical viewfinder and continuous shooting performance and expandability of an SLR, but gaining a live LCD preview (on a rotating LCD no less). Photo quality is very similar between the R1 and D-SLRs, so in the end you must decide which features you want to gain and which features you're willing to give up. |
|
| Review Site |
Review Score |
Date |
Link |
| Imaging-Resource |
7.95 |
11-19-05 |
Read Full Review
|
| Updated: The Sony DSC-R1 is a really compelling entry in the high-end "enthusiast" category. It offers a nearly unique focal length range, with truly exceptional optical quality, attractive color rendering, and very appealing tonality in its images. - Bottom line, we just liked looking at the R1's images. We found some of its ergonomics decidedly awkward, and both timing performance and high-ISO noise levels aren't up to the best of the digital SLRs currently on the market. On the other hand though, achieving the optical performance of the R1's lens with a conventional removable-lens SLR would cost literally thousands of dollars in high-end glass. |
|
| Review Site |
Review Score |
Date |
Link |
| PC Magazine |
7.29 |
12-02-05 |
Read Full Review
|
| For the first time, a Sony camera-the 10.3-megapixel Cyber-shot DSC-R1 ($999.95 list)-is using the large CMOS sensor the company developed in-house. (In the past, Sony manufactured the sensors strictly for sale, making them available only to D-SLR manufacturers.) The electronics giant believes this enthusiast camera's picture quality will compete with that of D-SLRs and hopes that the fixed-lens design will lure photographers who aren't interested in swapping optics. |
|
| Review Site |
Review Score |
Date |
Link |
| LetsGoDigital |
6.33 |
01-22-06 |
Read Full Review
|
| "For many years now, Sony have been enjoying a high ranking in the top 5 list of the most popular and bestselling camera brands. With the introduction of the Sony R1, they strengthen their position and, for now, apply sufficient counter-pressure to the strongly increasing uprising of digital reflex cameras. The Sony Cybershot R1 has most impressive specifications and will for many be an appealing alternative to the digital reflex camera. We have been in the position to test just how the Sony Cybershot R1 holds itself in practice.
Let it be clear that the Sony Cybershot DSC-R1 is an extraordinary camera indeed. This doesn't just limit itself to the design, but also covers the optics. The fact that the Sony R1 is equipped with a Carl Zeiss Vario-Sonnar T* lens greatly attributes to the test results. The Cybershot R1 really is a digital camera that awakens one's enthusiasm. Working with the camera in practice is pleasant and will without a doubt raise the heartbeat of the avid photographer!" |
|
| Review Site |
Review Score |
Date |
Link |
| Luminous-Landscape |
6.00 |
11-24-05 |
Read Full Review
|
| Part of American political folklore, and now of popular rhetoric as well, is the phrase – "It's the economy, stupid." It was made famous by political strategist James Carville, who put it on a sign in Bill Clinton's campaign office during the 1992 elections – to remind everyone what the real issue of that election was.
It's apt for paraphrasing when it comes to the brand new (Nov, '05) Sony DSC-R1 camera. The R1 is the first fixed lens digital camera (FLD) to feature an almost APS sized imaging chip. Note that I refer to the R1 as a fixed lens camera rather than the somewhat pejorative appellation"digicam", because though styled like one, and functionally similar in many ways, the R1 really is the first of a new breed. I may even coin the acronym FLD – Fixed Lens Digital, to help differentiate from DSLRs. |
|
| Review Site |
Review Score |
Date |
Link |
| Digital Trends |
5.75 |
11-09-05 |
Read Full Review
|
| Hands-On Preview: his is probably the most anticipated digital camera this season and it's due to be officially introduced mid-November for under $1,000. The just-introduced 12.8MP Canon EOS 5D ($3,299) was the other object de lust since it's the world's "smallest and lightest" full frame D-SLR. With full frame cameras there's no "digital factor" so all lenses including fish-eyes are their true focal lengths. Before the 5D you'd have to spend seven grand to get this convenience. At this price the 5D is targeted to very serious photographers; the DSC-R1 is for mere mortals.
There are no definitive conclusions to reach at this time but this camera offers a cornucopia of photographic delights. It's in a strange spot since it's the price of a quality D-SLR but doesn't offer the flexibility of interchangeable lenses, a potential deal breaker for many photographers. Your usual rambunctious reviewer will hold his fire for a couple of weeks. That said-unless Sony seriously falls flat on their faces- the DSC-R1 has the potential to be our camera of the year. |
|
| Review Site |
Review Score |
Date |
Link |
| CNET Reviews |
----- |
10-12-05 |
Read Full Review
|
Sony's Cyber Shot DSC-R1 represents an intriguing bridge between the world of user-friendly all-in-one prosumer cameras and the more complicated world of high-quality digital SLRs. It has an easily rotated LCD screen, plenty of manual bells and whistles, a sharp and versatile Carl Zeiss lens, and a 10-megapixel CMOS sensor nearly as large as those found in typical dSLRs. The resulting images are impressive, and the Sony Cyber Shot DSC-R1 is relatively easy to operate once you've navigated through the slightly awkward interface a few times.
 |
|
| Review Site |
Review Score |
Date |
Link |
| Digital Camera Info |
----- |
04-05-06 |
Read Full Review
|
| Review: "The Sony DSC-R1 made news as the first all-in-one camera with a DSLR-sized sensor and a gorgeous, Zeiss-labeled zoom lens fixed to the camera body. The R1 lists for just a nickel under $1000, but based on the specs – 10 megapixel 21.5 x 14.4mm CMOS sensor, 24-120mm-equivalent zoom lens, rotating 2-inch live view LCD – it should pose tough competition for the sub-$1000 DSLR-and-lens packages on the market.
The Sony R1 will ultimately serve a small portion of consumers quite well: sightseers, realtors, and those looking for a casual high-performance imager without concern for speed. The quality rivals or surpasses many entry-level DSLR kits and will not disappoint those willing to invest $1,000 for it." |
|
| Review Site |
Review Score |
Date |
Link |
| Popular Photography |
----- |
12-20-05 |
Read Full Review
|
| "The best advice we've ever given our readers? Take a camera for a test spin before buying, even if that means dry-firing it at the counter. If you're ready to move up from a compact digital camera and pick up Sony's new 10.3MP Cyber-shot DSC-R1 ($1,000 street), there's a good chance you'll buy it and return to the store only for more memory cards. But if you're looking to upgrade from your trusty old 35mm SLR system, or even a two-year old 6MP DSLR, the Sony DSC-R1 might leave you cold.
This may be the first EVF camera without video and sound capture; those moving up from a digital compact may miss it. Maybe Sony simply wanted to underscore how serious the DSC-R1 is about still photos."
|
|
|
|
|
|
HOT DEALS
|
|
Panasonic Lumix DMC-GF1K-K Black Digital Camera with 14-45mm Lens
|
|
Samsung HMX-R10 Digital HD Flash Hybrid Camcorder (9MP Stills)
|
|
RiData 8GB Lightning-Series SDHC Memory Card (Class 6)
|
|
Tamrac Expedition 3 - DSLR Photo Backpack
|
|
Q-Memory 16GB CompactFlash Memory Card (Fast 150x)
|
|
Tamron AF 18-270mm f/3.5-6.3 Di-II VC LD Aspherical (IF) Macro Lens
|
|
Canon 70-200mm f/2.8L IS Telephoto Zoom Lens
|
|
Canon 50mm f/1.8 Standard EF II Lens
|
|