FREE!      Cameratown Newsletter

Home New Models Cameras News Deals Video Reviews Firmware Manuals Free Software Rebates Shopping

Cameratown Sponsors








Ron Risman's
Video Portfolio

Digital Photography Reviews

View All Product Reviews Back to Referring Page

Canon EOS 5D Digital SLR Review

Review Summary
Reader Score: 7.50 (out of 10)
Canon's press material for the EOS 5D states that it 'defines (a) new D-SLR category', while we're not typically too concerned with marketing talk this particular statement is clearly pretty accurate. The EOS 5D is unlike any previous digital SLR in that it combines a full-frame (35 mm sized) high resolution sensor (12.8 megapixels) with a relatively compact body (slightly larger than the EOS 20D, although in your hand it feels noticeably 'chunkier'). The EOS 5D is aimed to slot in between the EOS 20D and the EOS-1D professional digital SLR's, an important difference when compared to the latter is that the EOS 5D doesn't have any environmental seals. While Canon don't specifically refer to the EOS 5D as a 'professional' digital SLR it will have obvious appeal to professionals who want a high quality digital SLR in a body lighter than the EOS-1D. It will also no doubt appeal to current EOS 20D owners (although lets hope they've not bought too many EF-S lenses...)
After reading this FULL REVIEW
Let others know if it was informative
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Other Reviews For This Model

Review Site Review Score Date Link
DCResource 10.00 01-17-06 Read Full Review
"The 5D is larger than the 20D, but it's not nearly as large as the monster known as the 1Ds Mk II. The 5D is built like a tank, and I'm confident that it can handle almost anything you throw at it. The 5D's full-frame sensor means that a 50 mm lens really is 50 mm, and not 80 mm like on the 20D. The camera has a large 2.5" LCD with plenty of resolution, and the optical viewfinder shows 96% of the frame. Two things missing from the body include a built-in flash (you'll need to use the hot shoe or flash sync port for that) and an AF-assist lamp.

It's hard not to like the EOS-5D. It offers amazing performance and photo quality and a full-frame sensor in a body that doesn't weigh almost three pounds (like the 1Ds Mk II). If you want a camera that lets your lenses be used as intended (without any crop factors) then it may be worth spending the extra cash on the 5D over the 20D. If all this full-frame isn't too important to you, the 20D will probably satisify you as well. Whichever one you choose you'll have an excellent digital SLR."





Review Site Review Score Date Link
The Digital Picture 9.38 10-20-05 Read Full Review
The Canon EOS 5D will appeal to both advanced amateurs and professionals who need or want very high image quality, wide angle field of view and/or shallow depth of field but do not require a high continuous frame rate, durability or weather and dust sealing. Those needing higher frame rates (typically sports and sometimes wildlife photographers) should consider the Canon EOS 20D or the Canon EOS 1D Mark II N as alternatives. Those wanting the ultimate image quality should consider the Canon EOS 1DS Mark II - an incredible camera.



Review Site Review Score Date Link
Imaging-Resource 9.00 04-03-06 Read Full Review
Review: "Built around a 12.8-megapixel (effective) CMOS sensor, covering the same area as a 35mm film frame, the Canon EOS 5D provides "full frame" digital SLR technology at a much more affordable price point than ever before. "Affordable" is definitely a relative term though, as the Canon 5D's $3500 retail price (at announcement) still puts it beyond the reach of all but the most well-heeled photo enthusiasts and professionals.

While a truly excellent photographic tool though, it doesn't automatically represent a slam-dunk choice between it and a sub-frame camera - or even between it and the much more expensive EOS-1Ds Mark II. The 5D struck us as an odd mixture of consumer and professional aesthetics, a slightly uncomfortable fit in the current world of d-SLRs. For people addicted to ultrawide angle photography with a substantial investment in full-frame wide angle lenses, it will probably be a no-brainer. But for someone not already invested in wide-angle glass, you could buy an EOS-30D and Canon's excellent little 10-22mm EF-S wide-angle lens and have more than just change to spare relative to the cost of the 5D body alone."





Review Site Review Score Date Link
Outback Photo 8.50 10-05-05 Read Full Review
Instead of a typical review, Uwe Steinmueller of Digital Outback Photo has started a review diary of the Canon EOS 5D. His diary started today (Oct 5, 2005) and will continue as he uncovers more findings during use. Some of his initial findings have been the excellent, bright and large, viewfinder; that the mirror is softer and has lower noise than the 1D series, and that the camera, while solid, is not built like the 1D series, which are built like tanks.



Review Site Review Score Date Link
Popular Photography 8.50 11-22-05 Read Full Review
Canon's New EOS 5D DSLR ($3,300 street, body only) is a study in the yin and yang of camera design. On the one hand, its 12.8MP full-frame CMOS sensor eliminates the 35mm lens factor found on all lower-priced DSLRs and gives it a potential image-quality edge. On the other hand, it costs more than twice as much as the 8.2MP EOS 20D ($1,300 street) from which it was cloned, and it's missing a few of the 20D's features. So you might ask, if the EOS 5D takes a picture in the woods and nobody hears it, does it make a sound purchase? Put simply, yes. Which is why we made it our 2005 Camera of the Year.



Review Site Review Score Date Link
Bob Atkins 8.40 02-27-06 Read Full Review
"The EOS 5D is a good compromise for a significant number of photographers. It combines high image quality with the ability to fully utilize EF series wideangle lenses (like the EF 16-35/2.8L). If 3fps is a fast enough frame rate (and for most photographers, it is) and don't need to regularly shoot outdoors in pouring rain, at around $4200 less than it's nearest full frame competitor (the EOS 1Ds Mk II) it's a very attractive camera. Under most shooting circumstances it produces higher quality images than the EOS 20D and it's undeniably a nicer camera to use with the larger viewfinder, clearer LCD screen and additional firmware functions such as the style modes and RGB histogram."



Review Site Review Score Date Link
Photo.net 8.30 01-02-06 Read Full Review
"The Canon EOS 5D is really the first practical, affordable, generally useful full frame Digital SLR. Sure there is the Canon EOS 1Ds MkII, but it currently sells for $7200 while the 5D's street price is now just under $3000. Yes, there was the Kodak DCS Pro 14n, but the fact that it's no longer made tells you something about it. OK in a studio maybe, but not really a practical camera for general use.

The EOS 5D is a good compromise for a sizable number of photographers who want high image quality combined with the ability to shoot wide-angle without resorting to EF-S lenses (in fact you don't have the option since EF-S lenses won't mount on the 5d) and who would like the advantages of full frame (e.g. smaller DOF). If you don't need super high frame rates and don't need to regularly shoot outdoors in pouring rain, at around $4200 less than it's nearest full frame competitor (the EOS 1Ds Mk II), it's a very attractive camera."





Review Site Review Score Date Link
Camera Labs 8.18 05-23-06 Read Full Review
Review: "Canon's EOS-5D is the first 'affordable' digital SLR with a full-frame sensor. Launched in October 2005, it represented a new product category for Canon, delivering 12.8 Megapixel resolution and the full-frame benefits of the high-end EOS-1Ds Mark II, while enjoying a price much closer to the consumer range.

We've had a chance to try the 5D with a number of lenses ranging in focal length from 17 to 400mm, and have also spoken to numerous existing owners to learn about their own experiences. Our extended review period has additionally allowed us to compare the 5D against Canon's latest EOS-30D along with what's probably its closest rival, the Nikon D200.

Build-wise the EOS-5D may be little more than a 20D or 30D with a higher resolution, full-frame sensor, but the resolving power is a big step-up from 6 and 8 Megapixel cameras, and while you may need technical charts to notice any detail advantage over Nikon's D200, the benefits of the low noise full-frame sensor are clear and rivalled only by Canon's high-end 1Ds Mark II."





Review Site Review Score Date Link
Digital Camera Info 8.07 03-28-06 Read Full Review
Head-to-Head: "The Nikon D200 – Canon EOS 5D Head-to-Head Review marks the debut of our comparative review format. There's plenty of debate about whether the 10.2 megapixel Nikon D200, at $1700, and the $3200, 12.8 MP full-frame Canon EOS 5D even ought to be compared – the price and sensor size differences are often cited points. But here's why we think it's useful to look at them together: first, the D200 and the 5D are the latest cameras from the leading DSLR manufacturers, and are the results of big R&D efforts. As such, they ought to show where the two companies are going, and what they're capable of. Second, they are Canon and Nikon's step-down models to their flagship DSLRs – both the EOS 5D and D200 represent more affordable, scaled-down versions of their top of the line cousins, with the full-frame 5D a smaller iteration of the 1Ds Mark II, and the D200 a mid-level D2X. We've heard plenty of Nikon partisans argue that the D200 competes more directly with the Canon EOS 30D, but really, the 30D is essentially the Canon EOS 20D with an interface upgrade – the chip and image processor are unchanged - so technologically, the camera is over a year and a half old.

The D200 is a much faster camera with a more logical ergonomic design. With the Nikon, users can turn the camera on and snap off a shot in a single motion - an action that would require two hands and far more time with the 5D. The D200 can also shoot 5 frames a second, while the 5D can only muster 3. This combined with the D200’s more robust body (not to mention its more affordable price tag), makes it a much more formidable alternative for photojournalists or casual shooters."





Review Site Review Score Date Link
Luminous-Landscape 8.00 08-24-05 Read Full Review
Preview: In a nut-shell, the 5D is a 13 Megapixel full-frame DSLR. What sets it apart from any prior full-frame DSLR, such as the 1 Ds Series Canon's or the now-defunct Kodak DCS 14n and Pro n models is that it is about the physical size of the current generation of 6 and 8 Megapixel cameras, as well as current film-based SLRs such as the Canon 1V. It's the first high-resolution full-frame digital SLR that can make this claim.



Review Site Review Score Date Link
PC Advisor 8.00 02-03-06 Read Full Review
"Canon's EOS 5D is a 12.8Mp (megapixel) D-SLR, or digital single-lens reflex, designed for serious enthusiasts and professionals. It's the first affordable D-SLR with a full-frame sensor, widely considered to be the Holy Grail of digital photography.

Build quality and ergonomics are excellent, with the 5D looking and feeling like a slightly larger version of the earlier 20D. Measuring 152x113x75mm and weighing 810g without battery, it's also considerably smaller and lighter than Canon's flagship full-frame body, the 1Ds Mark II.

Canon's EOS 5D is the most affordable full-frame D-SLR yet, allowing lenses to be used without affecting their field of view. At £2,539 for the body alone, it's quite a premium to pay even considering the 12.8Mp resolution. But if you curse the cropped view of cheaper D-SLRs, this could be the camera you've been waiting for."





Review Site Review Score Date Link
ePhotoZine 7.83 06-16-06 Read Full Review
Review: "Ever since digital cameras were first introduced, many photographers have hankered after the large viewfinder and depth-of-field they were used to with their 35mm SLR. The Canon EOS 5D is the first full-frame digital SLR to be released with an affordable price tag. In this review Gary Wolstenholme takes a look at whether Canon's full-frame revolution is all it's cracked up to be.

The Canon EOS 5D is a very capable camera, which produces silky smooth images right up to ISO400 and beyond that, noise levels are still very well controlled thanks in part to the full frame sensor. Sensor size is also to blame for another trait, vignetting with wide angle lenses is a real problem if you like to shoot wide open."





Review Site Review Score Date Link
LetsGoDigital 7.77 10-21-05 Read Full Review
The main sales argument for the Canon EOS 5D is of course the large sensor. It's a full-size image sensor meaning that the dimensions equal the 35mm format. And this means you don't suffer from focal length multiplier anymore, and this is especially ideal for wide angle lovers. Producing a full-size sensor is extremely expensive, more so because there is a lot of remainder of the wafers that the sensors are made from. You'd expect Canon to use the same sensor they've used for the EOS 1Ds Mark II, because the higher the production numbers, the lower the price will be per unit. But Canon decided to put an entirely new 12 Megapixel CMOS into the EOS 5D. It has a pixel pitch of 0.082 mm which equals the pixel pitch of speed monster; Eos-1D Mark II N. It is therefore well possible that the EOS 5D features a larger type than the one used in the EOS-1D Mark II N. Some image characteristics seem to prove this thought.



Review Site Review Score Date Link
Shutterbug 7.44 02-10-06 Read Full Review
"Will the 5D meet the needs of professionals and serious enthusiasts adequately enough to fend off what a little more resolution or other minor upgrades might offer? My impression from using the camera and the resultant images is that photographers are going to be satisfied with the product and its performance for some time to come. Sure, bigger, better, and faster is the constant siren song of the marketplace. But the Canon EOS 5D might just stave off that clarion call for quite a while."



Review Site Review Score Date Link
Think Camera 7.00 09-22-06 Read Full Review
Review: "The first digital SLR to combine a full-frame sensor with an affordable price tag, the Canon EOS 5D looks the part with a textured black case and a slew of controls. Pricier SLRs are heavier too; the lighter weight and grooved grip make it comfortable to hold for a long session (although hefty lenses will cause more imbalances).

The EOS 5D isn't the ideal camera for everyone and there are some minor compromises as well as some excellent features. It isn't a point and shoot camera by any means and both the body and the price tag are substantial - but it's smaller and better priced than many full-frame sensor cameras. If this is your first foray up the chain of D-SLR's and you don't want to spend too much first time round, the EOS-5D is a good starting point."





Review Site Review Score Date Link
Digital Camera Info 6.75 10-17-05 Read Full Review
Following our period of evaluation with the Canon EOS 5D, we can fully confirm that the camera is indeed all it's slated to be. Images produced with the camera's 35.8mm x 23.9mm 12.8 megapixel full frame CMOS sensor were sharp and contained low noise. While the camera is not meant for speed, its 4-channel readout and DIGIC II processor handled volumes of large files with ease – processing 15 RAW images in under 22 seconds. However, the biggest surprise was the effectiveness of the newly implemented Picture Style settings. While it is slightly deceiving at first (since "0's" are not equal to other "0" settings), the amount of control provided by the parameters was enlightening. Colors can be made to accurately reproduce the scene or slightly embellish the look and saturate the tones nicely, adding vibrancy. The design of the camera made it easy to handle and it fit my hands better than any Canon DSLR released to date. Other than a disappointing LCD screen and limited x-sync, the EOS 5D is about all consumers can ask for at a retail price of $3299. Currently, the 5D is truly without competition.



Review Site Review Score Date Link
Pocket-Lint 6.67 09-08-05 Read Full Review
First Look Preview: What we have here is a very highly specified machine indeed, but given its professional bent, there are a couple of surprising omissions. There's no water or dust resistance and there's no sound memo feature. While the latter is a minor omission, the former may be off putting, particularly for any professional that regularly shoots outdoors. However, given the projected pricing of the new camera of around £2540 ($3299 U.S.) it is still very temping, we'll just have to wait until the review sample arrives to see just how well it performs in earnest rather than the hands on look we got while at the launch.



Review Site Review Score Date Link
Digital Trends 6.00 01-11-06 Read Full Review
"This is a terrific D-SLR as one would expect for the price. There's no getting away from the fact it's the smallest and lightest full-frame D-SLR available and it delivers superb picture quality. Digital noise is practically a thing of the past. But you'll pay for the privilege (figure $5K if you're starting from scratch for a quality EF lens or three and a Speedlight flash). This is a serious commitment and I would have no reservation recommending it if the 5D cost closer to $2,000 for the body instead of three grand. Given its high price I suggest prospective D-SLR purchasers with more limited resources look at the many kits available for less than $1,500. The 8.2MP Canon EOS 20D would be a good start since it's operationally very similar and costs $1,400 for the body only in the real world."



Review Site Review Score Date Link
CNET Reviews ----- 11-12-05 Read Full Review
For some photographers, a sensor the same size as a frame of 35mm film (24mm by 36mm)-often referred to as full frame-is the Holy Grail of digital SLR technology. It promises the familiar shooting experience in viewfinder size, in lens angle of view, and in certain aspects of a picture's look. Until now, this object of lust was available only at great expense ($7,000 or more) or in cameras with significant design and performance quirks. But Canon's EOS 5D changes that, combining a 12.8-megapixel, 23.9mm-by-35.8mm CMOS sensor with a competent midsize SLR body for less than half the price of the only full-frame alternative available at this writing, also a Canon, the EOS-1Ds Mark II.

Our test images from the Canon EOS 5D are superb overall. Its 12.8-megapixel sensor delivers loads of detail and smooth, rich tonality. The dynamic range in our photos equaled-or bested-the results from every other dSLR we've tested, with the exception of the Fujifilm S3 Pro. Noise in our ISO 1,600 and 3,200 test images is astonishingly low, yet detail is retained. It was easy for us to get natural, smooth skin tones with many complexions. All in all, this camera is a top choice for shooting portraits, still-lifes, landscapes, architecture, and some kinds of commercial studio subjects, especially if you need or want to make 16x20 or larger prints.





Twitter Counter for @cameratown







HOT DEALS
 
New Sony Cyber-shot DSC-HX5V/B with HD, GPS & Compass
Price: $349.95 Free Ship
OneCall
Panasonic Lumix DMC-GF1 with 14-45mm Lens (28-90mm Equivalent)
Price: $743.56 Free Ship
Amazon
Sony Cyber-shot DSC-W190 Digital Camera (Red)
Price: $119.99
NewEgg
Canon PowerShot SD960 IS Digital Camera (Free 2GB & Shipping)
Price: $199 Free 2GB & Ship
BuyDig
Adorama Mini Soft Box Diffuser for Shoe Mount Flashes
Price: $11.95
Adorama
HP (Hewlett-Packard) Officejet 7000 Inkjet Printer
Price: $149.99 Free Ship
HP Direct
Joby Professional Gorillapod Focus, Flexible Aluminum SLR Tripod
Price: $64.95 Free Ship
Adorama
Canon VIXIA HF S100 HD Flash Memory Camcorder (Free Xtra Battery)
Price: $693.54 Free Ship
Amazon
 
Copyright @2003-2010 Cameratown.com. All Rights Reserved. Terms of Use
All Rights Reserved. Reproduction in any form or medium without the
express written permission of Cameratown.com is prohibited.
Please email me with your suggestions or comments.